Book review
Towers of Midnight Review
Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson's penultimate Wheel of Time volume converts long-delayed promises into action while positioning many separate journeys for the Last Battle.
- Author
- Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson
- First published
- 2010
View source
https://openlibrary.org/works/OL15414340WTowers of Midnight review: the long series begins to collect its debts
This Towers of Midnight review argues that the thirteenth Wheel of Time novel succeeds primarily as payoff. Robert Jordan's series, completed by Brandon Sanderson after Jordan's death, has accumulated prophecies, vows, failures, artifacts, rivalries, and postponed confrontations across an enormous span. This penultimate volume turns many of those promises into decisions. The Last Battle is no longer distant atmosphere; preparation reshapes every major line.
The book follows an ensemble that includes Rand, Egwene, Perrin, Mat, and Aviendha, among many others. Its strongest sequences give long-running characters the action that confirms an internal change. Its weakest moments show the difficulty of synchronizing chronology, inherited voice, and a cast too large for equal attention. No newcomer should start here. This is fantasy as serial culmination.
A penultimate volume has a special burden
The book must create satisfaction without spending the final confrontation. It needs to close enough arcs to prove movement while preserving enough danger for A Memory of Light. Sanderson and Jordan's material meet that burden by emphasizing readiness. Characters acquire information, accept roles, settle conflicts, and choose what they will carry into the end.
This can make the novel feel like both destination and bridge. Certain episodes possess the force of conclusions; other chapters reposition pieces. Readers who have waited through slower middle volumes are likely to experience the density of payoff as relief. Those less attached to the full sequence may see machinery. The difference is not accidental. Emotional value here is stored across prior books.
Perrin's arc turns acceptance into skill
Perrin has long resisted leadership, violence, and aspects of his identity. Repetition has been part of that struggle, sometimes to reader frustration. In this volume, his development becomes materially demonstrable. Acceptance is not a speech but an ability to act with clearer purpose.
His strongest scenes connect craftsmanship, responsibility, and self-knowledge. Making and leading become related practices: both require attention to material, consequence, and the limits of force. The arc works because it does not erase reluctance. Perrin's moral caution remains valuable once it stops functioning as avoidance. For many readers, this is the volume in which his long hesitation finally yields narrative interest.
Mat's promised destination combines comedy and dread
Mat's path toward the Tower of Ghenjei fulfills one of the series' most persistent obligations. His voice and luck bring comic energy, but the rescue carries old grief and dangerous rules. The sequence condenses what the character does best: he complains, calculates, improvises, and remains more loyal than his self-description admits.
Some readers find Sanderson's rendering of Mat less natural than Jordan's, especially in the comic cadence. That concern remains relevant even when the plot succeeds. Completion requires imitation, interpretation, and change; no solution makes the transition invisible. The Tower sequence works because its structural stakes are strong enough to carry minor tonal discontinuities.
Rand and Egwene embody competing responsibilities
Rand's transformed bearing and Egwene's institutional authority bring them into conflict over how the Last Battle should be approached. Both act from responsibility, but they define legitimate risk differently. The disagreement is more interesting than a simple contest between wisdom and obstruction.
The series has always linked personal destiny to political consequence. Here that link tightens. Rand cannot make a world-ending decision as a private individual; Egwene cannot preserve institutional prudence by ignoring prophecy and change. Their conflict stages a question epic fantasy often avoids: who has standing to decide when exceptional danger appears to require exceptional action?
Aviendha makes victory morally uncertain
Aviendha's experience at Rhuidean expands the stakes beyond defeating the immediate enemy. Possible futures expose what a people may become after the celebrated victory. This is one of the book's most valuable interventions because it resists treating the Last Battle as the end of history.
The vision connects survival to culture, policy, and memory. Winning can still lead to dispossession or degradation if the peace is badly designed. That insight gives Aviendha a forward-looking role and places responsibility on choices made before victory. The sequence is disturbing precisely because it transforms prophecy from reassurance into warning.
Strengths: convergence with thematic unity
Despite the huge cast, the volume repeatedly returns to acceptance of responsibility. Perrin accepts leadership, characters honor difficult promises, rulers prepare for collective danger, and possible futures demand planning beyond personal survival. This theme prevents convergence from becoming only logistical.
The second strength is variety. Dream, diplomacy, battle, rescue, prophecy, and craft occupy distinct registers. The third is payoff discipline. Long-running objects and obligations matter. Compared with The Paradise War, which begins a portal fantasy transformation, Towers of Midnight operates at the opposite end of serial experience: almost every object arrives carrying history.
Cautions about scale, chronology, and voice
Readers need substantial recall. The text offers reminders, but no summary can recreate the emotional investment behind every return. The chronology of parallel plotlines can also feel uneven as events align across volumes. Momentum sometimes hides temporal seams rather than resolving them.
The shift in authorship remains visible in prose rhythm and some characterization. Sanderson's strengths in structure and payoff help the final sequence move, while certain voices may feel more explicit or comic in a different key. Evaluating the novel fairly means recognizing the extraordinary completion problem without pretending that necessity eliminates aesthetic difference.
Reader fit and alternatives
This book is for continuing readers, especially those invested in Mat and Perrin. It rewards memory, patience, and affection for the ensemble. It is not for someone sampling the series or looking for a compact epic fantasy.
For dragon-centered worldbuilding with a more contained entry, The Skies of Pern offers another kind of mature series context. Dogsbody compresses cosmic identity into a much smaller and more intimate fantasy. Readers who want to begin rather than culminate should choose The Paradise War. Towers of Midnight is valuable because beginning is long past.
What the book cannot finish yet
The Last Battle remains ahead, major political disagreement is unresolved, and some characters receive positioning rather than conclusion. This incompleteness is structurally honest. A penultimate volume should not counterfeit finality.
Still, the novel creates local endings strong enough to stand. Rescues occur, identities settle, and earlier choices acquire consequence. The balance between closure and anticipation is one reason the book feels faster than its size. Readers leave with fewer dormant promises and greater awareness of what the final book must answer.
The pattern also changes the emotional meaning of prophecy. Earlier in the series, foretelling often created distant expectation. Here prophecy is becoming a deadline against which institutions must choose. Knowledge of a possible future does not remove disagreement about how to reach or survive it. That distinction gives the preparatory chapters tension even when no immediate battle occurs: the characters are deciding which risks the last volume will inherit.
Final assessment
Towers of Midnight is not seamless. Its voices reflect collaborative completion, its timelines require tolerance, and its density excludes casual entry. Yet it performs the essential work of epic culmination: it remembers. Objects, fears, relationships, and prophecies carried across thousands of pages return with altered meaning.
The best sequences show that readiness is ethical rather than merely military. A person must accept a role without surrendering judgment; a people must imagine life beyond victory; leaders must argue about risks no one can fully measure. For readers who have traveled the entire road, the volume offers the rare pleasure of accumulated narrative obligation becoming action.